Ancillary Product Penetration & Refund Benchmarks 2026

Research compiled by Veritas Financial Services | Last updated: August 2026

Vehicle service contracts are attached to 45% of financed vehicles and GAP to 40%, and when those loans end early the unused portion of each product becomes an aftermarket product refund. The following report was compiled from data published between October 2024 and August 2026, aggregating datasets from StoneEagleDATA, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s add-on product study, NADA, JM&A Group, the Federal Reserve Board, and Experian, combined with Veritas’s pro rata refund model. It benchmarks penetration rates, product prices, refund amounts by cancellation month, and the loan events that trigger refunds, beginning with the penetration chart below.

Ancillary Product Penetration Rates

Ancillary Product Penetration on Financed Vehicles: 2026

Sources: Figure 11

Source note: Data compiled August 28, 2026.

The chart above and table below show how often each ancillary product is attached at the point of sale. Nearly three in four financed buyers add at least one product, and the two refundable staples, the vehicle service contract (VSC) and GAP, each reach four in ten deals.

Ancillary Product Penetration by Product: 2026

ProductPenetration RatePopulationData Period
Any add-on product71.8%Borrowers**2018-2022
Any add-on product, new vehicles68.9%Borrowers**2018-2022
Any add-on product, used vehicles75.4%Borrowers**2018-2022
Vehicle service contract45%Dealer-delivered unitsQ1 2026
Vehicle service contract, new vehicles47.2%Franchised dealers2023
GAP40%Dealer-delivered unitsQ1 2026
Paint and fabric protection20%Dealer-delivered unitsQ1 2026

Sources: Table 22

**Non-servicemember borrowers.

Used-vehicle buyers attach products more often than new-vehicle buyers, 75.4% versus 68.9%, which matters for refund planning because used-vehicle loans also carry higher trade-in turnover. JM&A Group’s Q2 2026 trends report shows GAP leading year-over-year product performance and VSC penetration essentially flat (down 0.1 points from May 2026), with product income making up 61.8% of total F&I per-vehicle revenue in June 2026.

Ancillary Product Prices: The Refund Base

The refund on any product is a fraction of its purchase price, so price is the first benchmark. The CFPB’s study of 2018 to 2022 originations is the largest public dataset on what borrowers actually pay for add-ons:

Average Ancillary Product Cost per Borrower Who Purchased Add-Ons

Product or BundleAverage CostPopulation
Warranty, service, or maintenance plans$2,983Borrowers with the product*
GAP products$952Borrowers with the product*
Other add-on products$1,115Borrowers with the product*
All add-ons, new vehicles$3,196Borrowers with add-ons**
All add-ons, used vehicles$2,961Borrowers with add-ons**

Sources: Table 33

*Servicemember borrowers. **Non-servicemember borrowers.

Financed add-ons total roughly $3,000 per loan whether the vehicle is new or used. Because most buyers roll that amount into the loan, it is also the amount at stake when the loan terminates before the products expire.

Aftermarket Product Refund Amounts by Cancellation Month

Pro rata is the most common statutory refund method for service contracts and GAP waivers, and many product contracts use it as well: the unused share of the term multiplied by the purchase price. The table below applies that formula to the CFPB average prices, using a 72-month VSC term, the 69-month average new-vehicle loan term for GAP, and a 60-month term for other products. Figures are before any cancellation fee.

Modeled Pro Rata Refund by Product and Cancellation Month: 2026

ProductPurchase PriceTermRefund at Month 12Refund at Month 24Refund at Month 36Refund at Month 48
Vehicle service contract$2,98372 months$2,486$1,989$1,492$994
GAP$95269 months$786$621$455$290
Other aftermarket products (combined)$1,11560 months$892$669$446$223

Sources: Table 44

Read across a single loan and the numbers add up quickly. A borrower who financed a VSC, GAP, and one other product and paid the loan off at month 24 is owed about $3,300 in unearned charges; at month 36, about $2,400. Three adjustments move the final amount:

  • Cancellation fees: where a state permits one, a flat or percentage fee is deducted from pro rata refunds, and flat state caps range from $25 to $75; California has prohibited cancellation fees on GAP waivers since January 1, 2023, and Texas’s GAP statute contains no cancellation fee provision.
  • Free-look windows: cancellations inside the free-look window, which runs from 10 to 60 days depending on the state and product (30 days for Texas GAP waivers under Chapter 354), return 100% of the price rather than the pro rata share.
  • Claims paid: once a GAP benefit has been paid, no GAP refund is due in states such as California and Florida; for service contracts, some states, such as Florida, deduct claims paid from the refund.

Refund Triggers: How Often Loans End Early

A refund is only owed when the product outlives the loan, so the frequency of early loan termination sets the volume of refunds. The Federal Reserve Board’s 2024 study of prepayment across Equifax, Experian AutoCount, and securitized-loan data is the most complete benchmark:

Auto Loan Prepayment Benchmarks

Prepayment MeasureShare of Loans
Paid off at least 6 months before maturity70%
Fully repaid within the first 36 months45%
Paid off within the first 12 months15%
Prepayments attributable to a vehicle sale or trade-in15% to 30%
Zero-interest loans prepaid before maturityOver 50%

Sources: Table 55

Set those rates against today’s loan terms and the refund exposure per contract is clear. Experian’s Q4 2025 data puts the average new-vehicle loan at $43,582 over 68.9 months and the average used-vehicle loan at $27,528 over 67.7 months. With 45% of loans retired inside three years, nearly half of all ancillary products attached to a 69-month loan reach the refund stage with more than half of their term unused.

Refund Rules That Change the Amount

Refund amounts also depend on the state tied to the retail installment contract, not the borrower’s state of residence. Three of the largest refund-volume states illustrate the range:

  • Texas: GAP waivers sold under Finance Code Chapter 354 are capped at 5% of the amount financed; refunds are pro rata in practice (Texas rules set the Rule of 78s as the minimum), the statute contains no cancellation fee provision, and the refund must be issued or credited within 60 calendar days of early termination; no refund is required when the calculated amount is under $5. Debt cancellation agreements on direct consumer loans under Chapter 342 carry no statutory fee cap or refund method, so the contract terms control.
  • California: GAP waiver prices are capped at 4% of the amount financed, cancellation fees are prohibited, refunds are pro rata, and payment must be issued within 60 business days of early termination.
  • Most other states: contracts follow the administrator’s stated method, and refunds on an active loan are sent to the financial institution and applied to the balance, with the borrower paid directly only after payoff.

Every early payoff, trade-in, and total loss on a financed vehicle produces a pro rata refund obligation across an average of $3,000 in attached products, and with 70% of loans ending early, that obligation is the norm rather than the exception. Veritas provides fully managed, compliant ancillary product cancellation and refund services for auto lenders across all 50 states. To see how the process works end to end, schedule a demo with Veritas.

References:

1. Demand Local. (2026). 10 F&I product marketing and penetration statistics for dealers in 2026, citing StoneEagleDATA. https://www.demandlocal.com/blog/fi-product-marketing-penetration-statistics/

2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025, January). Auto lending to servicemembers: Add-on products, 2018-2022. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_servicemember-auto-finance-report_2025-01.pdf

3. F&I and Showroom. (2024). NADA: F&I income, penetration rates remain strong. https://www.fi-magazine.com/news/nada-fi-income-penetration-rates-remain-strong

4. JM&A Group. (2026, July). Automotive trends report: Q2 2026 results. https://www.jmagroup.com/resources/operations/automotive-trends-report

5. Federal Reserve Board. (2024). One month longer, one month later? Prepayments in the auto loan market (FEDS Working Paper 2024-056). https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2024056pap.pdf

6. LendingTree. (2026). Average car payment and auto loan statistics: 2026, citing Experian State of the Automotive Finance Market Q4 2025. https://www.lendingtree.com/auto/debt-statistics/

7. Texas Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner. (2020, July 21). Review of debt cancellation agreements requiring insurance: Common issues. https://occc.texas.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/b16-2-mvsf-dca-review-common-issues-072120.pdf

8. Wise F&I. (2023, January). Highlights of GAP changes in California, effective January 1, 2023. https://www.wisefandi.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/California-GAP-Changes-HIghlights-Effective-010123-v2.pdf

9. Texas Legislature. (2017). Finance Code Chapter 354: Debt cancellation agreements for certain retail vehicle installment sales. https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/FI/htm/FI.354.htm

10. RefundAuto. (2026). Auto refund calculator: Estimate your GAP and warranty refund. https://www.refundauto.com/calculator

11. Protective Asset Protection. (2026). GAP frequently asked questions. https://www.protectiveassetprotection.com/existing-customers/gapfrequentlyaskedquestions

1Figure 1

1. Demand Local. (2026). 10 F&I product marketing and penetration statistics for dealers in 2026, citing StoneEagleDATA. https://www.demandlocal.com/blog/fi-product-marketing-penetration-statistics/

2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025, January). Auto lending to servicemembers: Add-on products, 2018-2022. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_servicemember-auto-finance-report_2025-01.pdf

2Table 2

1. Demand Local. (2026). 10 F&I product marketing and penetration statistics for dealers in 2026, citing StoneEagleDATA. https://www.demandlocal.com/blog/fi-product-marketing-penetration-statistics/

2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025, January). Auto lending to servicemembers: Add-on products, 2018-2022. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_servicemember-auto-finance-report_2025-01.pdf

3. F&I and Showroom. (2024). NADA: F&I income, penetration rates remain strong. https://www.fi-magazine.com/news/nada-fi-income-penetration-rates-remain-strong

3Table 3

1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025, January). Auto lending to servicemembers: Add-on products, 2018-2022. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_servicemember-auto-finance-report_2025-01.pdf

4Table 4

1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2025, January). Auto lending to servicemembers: Add-on products, 2018-2022. https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_servicemember-auto-finance-report_2025-01.pdf

2. LendingTree. (2026). Average car payment and auto loan statistics: 2026, citing Experian State of the Automotive Finance Market Q4 2025. https://www.lendingtree.com/auto/debt-statistics/

3. Texas Office of Consumer Credit Commissioner. (2020, July 21). Review of debt cancellation agreements requiring insurance: Common issues. https://occc.texas.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/b16-2-mvsf-dca-review-common-issues-072120.pdf

5Table 5

1. Federal Reserve Board. (2024). One month longer, one month later? Prepayments in the auto loan market (FEDS Working Paper 2024-056). https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2024056pap.pdf